What do recent NSF GRFP reviewers look for in the intellectual merit section of proposals submitted by materials science PhD candidates.
Download run
Fan-out diagram
The searches the AI actually ran for this prompt.
SEED QUERY
What do recent NSF GRFP reviewers look for in the intellectual merit section of proposals submitted by materials science PhD candidates.
3 real searches · 1 real-search pass
NSF GRFP 2026 solicitation intellectual merit review criteria reviewer guidance graduate research fellowship materials scienceGoogle ↗
OBSERVEDReason
NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program reviewer handbook intellectual merit evaluation criteria proposal reviewGoogle ↗
OBSERVEDReason
NSF GRFP winning proposal materials science intellectual merit examples reviewer feedbackGoogle ↗
OBSERVEDReason
Badge and edge weight = share of passes that produced the query. Hover a query for its intent and routing format.
Query classes
Google's semantic query class for every sub-query: what kind of answer each search is after, simulated vs real.
ChatGPT real searches (3)
Classes come from the query-classifier (a local Laya model). 3 of 3 calls are low-confidence (under 50%) — hover a query in the table to see its confidence.
Searches and sources
ChatGPT3 real searches · gpt-6
NSF GRFP 2026 solicitation intellectual merit review criteria reviewer guidance graduate research fellowship materials science Google ↗
NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program reviewer handbook intellectual merit evaluation criteria proposal review Google ↗
NSF GRFP winning proposal materials science intellectual merit examples reviewer feedback Google ↗
- How Applications are Reviewed - NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program (NSF GRFP) · nsf.gov
- Information for Reviewers - NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program (NSF GRFP) · nsf.gov
- FAQ: Graduate Research Fellowship Program (GRFP) · nsf.gov
- Chapter III: NSF Proposal Processing and Review - Proposal & Award Policies & Procedures Guide (PAPPG) (NSF 23-1) · nsf.gov
- NSF 24-591: NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program (GRFP) · nsf-gov-resources.nsf.gov
- Graduate Research Fellowship Program (GRFP) · nsfgrfp.org
Queries
3 queries · click a column to sort
| Query / type | Search | Intent | Query class | Routing format | Cluster | Freq ↓ | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NSF GRFP 2026 solicitation intellectual merit review criteria reviewer guidance graduate research fellowship materials science OBSERVED | Google ↗ AI Mode ↗ | — | Reason | — | — | 1x of 1 | |
NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program reviewer handbook intellectual merit evaluation criteria proposal review OBSERVED | Google ↗ AI Mode ↗ | — | Reason | — | — | 1x of 1 | |
NSF GRFP winning proposal materials science intellectual merit examples reviewer feedback OBSERVED | Google ↗ AI Mode ↗ | — | Reason | — | — | 1x of 1 |